Review: Permanence by Sophie Mackintosh

Permanence by Sophie Mackintosh

Blurb from Goodreads:

Clara and Francis are in love, but nobody knows it. For months they have been stealing away from their respective lives, leaving no trace of their relationship behind. Their time together is always excruciatingly sweet and all too short. Until one day they wake up in an apartment neither of them recognizes, with no memory of how they got there.

They find themselves in a new, unnamed city, a self-contained sanctuary where adulterers live openly as couples. Here there are fountains and old town squares and perfect cafes with checkered tablecloths. Ripe fruits wait on the counter each morning, invisible threads bind each lover to the other, and their primary responsibility is to enjoy one another. Contact with the real world is impossible and the city’s whims are mysterious—but now those stolen afternoons never have to end.

How much would you sacrifice for a life you never thought possible? And how long can you stay in paradise before the cracks start to show?

An exploration of desire, novelty, and choice, Permanence explores the tantalizing quandary of what, if anything, can withstand the daily toll of “forever”.

 This was fine but definitely not as nuanced as I expected.  It was like taking the worst parts of a relationship and compounding them and throwing them in your face.  I'm not sure but it felt very critical of the underlying choices in the worst way rather than trying to explain the characters better.  It also felt very surface in explaining this complex choice and world.  The premise is amazing but it underwhelmed me, overall.

Permanence comes out next week on April 21, 2026 and you can purchase HERE.  

She did not understand. She had been given what she had always wanted, and it had been taken away. A brief, delirious dream. Better not to have seen it, she thought. Better not to have known.